---
title: Cluster Planting and Forest Succession
description: Explore innovative cluster planting at Bob O Link Greenspace, promoting natural forest succession to enhance biodiversity and soil health.
---

[blog](https://bobolink-greenspace.com/blog)

# [Cluster Planting and Forest Succession](https://bobolink-greenspace.com/blog/cluster-planting-and-forest-succession)

 Written by [Jennifer](https://bobolink-greenspace.com/blog/author/jennifer) | Nov 17, 2026, 6:09:35 PM

 

*A new demonstration site at Bob O Link Greenspace is testing a simple idea: plant a young forest the way nature builds one, in layered clusters, then step back and let it grow up.*

Most tree plantings follow a familiar pattern. Trees go in evenly spaced rows, grass gets mowed between them, and success means every sapling is still alive a few years later. That approach produces shade trees. It rarely produces a forest.

At Bob O Link, we are trying something different. As the high, dry, rocky strip of the greenspace dips towards backyards, we have started a **cluster-planted native microforest**. It is a living demonstration of how forest succession works and how planting in diverse, layered groups can build better habitat for wildlife, pollinators and the soil itself.

This post explains the thinking behind the project: what succession is, why we plant in clusters, what benefits we expect, and how we will track whether it is working.

## What is forest succession?

Forest succession is how open ground becomes a forest over time. It does not happen all at once. It happens through a series of plant communities, and each one changes conditions in a way that sets up the next.

In Central Kentucky, an abandoned field left alone will typically move through stages like these:

1. **Open ground and early colonizers.** Sun-loving wildflowers and grasses, such as goldenrods, asters and ironweed, move in first and cover the soil.
2. **Shrubs and pioneer trees.** Fast-growing woody plants such as sassafras, black cherry, sycamore and tulip poplar take hold and start casting shade.
3. **A mixed young forest.** As shade builds, sun-loving plants decline and shade-tolerant species like spicebush, pawpaw and dogwood fill in beneath.
4. **A mature, self-renewing forest.** Long-lived oaks and hickories eventually rise into the canopy, with younger trees of the same species waiting below to replace them.

Left to its own pace, this process can take many decades. And on disturbed, compacted ground surrounded by mowed turf and invasive shrubs, it may never get started. The forest can stall at a thicket of bush honeysuckle instead.

That is where planting comes in. A micro-forest does not skip succession. It **gives succession a head start** by installing several layers of the future forest at once, then letting natural competition sort out the rest.

Two trees that both grow to 80 feet can play very different roles along the way. A fast-growing pioneer like tulip poplar shoots up early and provides shade and structure. A slow-growing white oak develops alongside it and may not reach the canopy for decades. Over time, competition, mortality and canopy gaps gradually reorganize the planting. Some trees win, some are suppressed and some die. That is not failure. That is a forest forming.

## Why plant in clusters?

A natural forest is not a grid of identical trees. It is layered from the forest floor to the canopy, and it changes from one spot to the next with soil, moisture and light. Cluster planting copies both of those patterns.

### Building every layer at once

Each cluster includes plants from every level of the future forest:

| **Forest layer** | **Mature height** | **Examples** | **Role in the forest** |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Overstory / canopy | 50–100+ ft | White oak, bur oak, chinkapin oak, shagbark hickory, tulip poplar, sycamore | The dominant future canopy |
| Understory / subcanopy | 20–50 ft | Blackgum, redbud, serviceberry, pawpaw, flowering dogwood, American hornbeam | Fills space beneath and between canopy trees |
| Shrubs | 3–20 ft | Spicebush, hazelnut, witch hazel, viburnums, wild hydrangea, coralberry | Woody middle layer, thickets and edges for wildlife |
| Herbaceous | 0–6 ft | Goldenrods, asters, ironweed, woodland sunflower, native grasses | Covers soil early; feeds pollinators |
| Ground layer | 0–2 ft | Woodland sedges, wild ginger, Jacob's ladder, ferns, trillium | The eventual forest-floor community |

As a starting point, each cluster is planted at roughly **25% canopy trees, 25% understory trees, 25% shrubs and 25% herbaceous and ground-layer plants**. We do not expect that balance to last. Succession will shift it, and that is the point.

We also track each plant's **successional role**, not just its height. Some species are pioneers that thrive early and fade as shade builds. Others are late-succession species that will persist for generations. Mixing both gives the cluster structure now and staying power later.

### Small ecological neighborhoods

Instead of spreading every species evenly across the site, each cluster is designed as a small "ecological neighborhood" suited to its spot. Twenty to forty feet away, the recipe changes. Three examples:

- **Upland / limestone cluster:** chinkapin oak, bur oak, shagbark hickory, redbud, serviceberry, hazelnut, coralberry and native grasses and sedges.
- **Mesic (moderately moist) cluster:** white oak, shagbark hickory, blackgum, serviceberry, spicebush, witch hazel, woodland sedges, wild ginger and Jacob's ladder.
- **Stream-influenced cluster:** sycamore, river birch, shellbark hickory, pawpaw, spicebush, elderberry, buttonbush in truly wet spots, and moisture-loving sedges.

The guiding rule is to plant what the site could naturally support rather than simply cramming in as many species as possible. This idea comes from the Miyawaki method, which builds plantings around the "potential natural vegetation" of a place based on its climate, soil and topography.

## A richer home for wildlife and pollinators

Layers create habitat. A mowed lawn with a few shade trees offers wildlife two options: grass or canopy. A layered cluster offers dozens of niches stacked on top of each other.

- **Food through the seasons.** Redbud and serviceberry bloom in early spring, when bees have few other options. Summer brings elderberry, hydrangea and woodland flowers. Goldenrods and asters carry pollinators into fall. Oaks, hickories, hazelnuts, pawpaws and viburnums produce nuts and fruit for birds and mammals.
- **Host plants for caterpillars.** Many native insects can only feed on native plants. Oaks support an especially large number of moth and butterfly species, and those caterpillars are what songbirds feed their young. Spicebush, sassafras and pawpaw each host their own specialist butterflies.
- **Cover and nesting space.** Dense shrubs and thickets give birds safe places to nest and hide from predators. The ground layer, leaf litter and fallen wood shelter insects, amphibians and small mammals.
- **Edges and gaps.** Because clusters vary and canopy gaps will form, the site will hold sunny edges, dappled light and deep shade side by side. Different species use each one.

Diversity also builds resilience. When a planting depends on one or two species, a single pest, disease or drought can wipe it out. A cluster with many species across many layers can absorb losses and keep functioning.

## Rebuilding the soil from the ground up

The least visible benefit may be the most important. A soil assessment of the greenspace found what is common on disturbed urban land: **dense, compacted soil** that sheds water, starves roots of air and struggles to support life.

Compacted soil didn't form overnight, and it won't be fixed overnight either. Rather than relying on heavy machinery or a quick fix, our approach puts the plants in charge and gives them time. The layered planting itself becomes the long-term soil-building system. Each layer works the ground in a different way, and season by season, they rebuild it together:

- **Roots at every depth.** Grasses and sedges hold the surface. Shrub roots work the middle. Oak and hickory taproots go deep. Together they open channels that let air and water move through the soil again.
- **A constant supply of organic matter.** Every fall, leaves from four layers of plants drop to the ground. Unlike a lawn, nothing is raked or bagged. That litter breaks down into the dark, crumbly topsoil found on a forest floor.
- **Underground partnerships.** Most native trees and shrubs form relationships with mycorrhizal fungi, which extend the reach of roots and help bind soil particles together. A diverse planting supports a diverse soil community.
- **Protected, cooler ground.** A closing canopy and a covered forest floor shield soil from baking sun and pounding rain, reducing erosion and keeping moisture in.
- **Better water handling.** On a floodplain site, healthier soil soaks up more rainfall and lets less run off, which also benefits the nearby stream.

Over time, healthy soil and a healthy forest reinforce each other. Better soil grows stronger plants, and stronger plants build better soil.

## Letting the forest decide

The hardest part of this project may be knowing when **not** to step in. Our guiding principle: *intervention will decrease as ecological function increases.* We manage to protect native succession, not to keep a tidy landscape.

In practice, volunteers sort what they see into three levels:

| Level | What it looks like | What we do |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Green: observe** | One native shading another; lower branches dying back; uneven growth; leaves piling up; sun-loving flowers fading as shade increases; native seedlings popping up in unexpected places | Nothing. This is what succession looks like. |
| **Yellow: watch** | One native species becoming unusually dominant; repeated deer browse; the shrub layer disappearing; rising bare ground; oaks being heavily suppressed | Record it, photograph it, and ask whether nature will likely resolve it on its own. |
| **Red: intervene** | Invasives spreading; severe erosion; browse preventing establishment; pest or disease threats; safety hazards | Act early, using the least intervention needed. |

### Native competition is not the same as invasive competition

When natives compete, we usually watch. When non-native invasives compete, we act early. In Central Kentucky the usual suspects are **bush honeysuckle, Callery (Bradford) pear, privet, multiflora rose, wintercreeper and garlic mustard**. Dense honeysuckle stands can displace native plants and stall forest regeneration. Callery pear often resprouts after cutting, so it needs follow-up treatment.

### We don't automatically replace every loss

If three of twenty trees die, we don't simply plant three more. We first ask why. We replace plants when a loss leaves a major structural hole, wipes out a species, or results from abnormal causes like drought or wildlife damage. We don't replace them when neighboring natives are filling the space or natural seedlings are moving in.

That is the shift from gardening to forest stewardship.

## How we'll know it's working

We won't define success as "90% of what we planted is still alive." A cluster can have excellent survival and still be headed nowhere, if invasives are moving in or no young trees are growing up underneath. Instead, we ask a different question:

> Is this cluster moving toward a diverse, self-replacing native forest?

### Permanent clusters and photo points

Each cluster will be given a permanent ID (CL-01, CL-02, etc.) and a marked photo point. Volunteers can photograph each cluster from the same spot and direction every year, building a visual record of the forest taking shape. Seasonal check-ins watch for drought, wildlife damage, erosion and invasives. A formal inventory happens each fall.

### A 32-point succession score

Each year, every cluster is scored from 0 to 4 on eight indicators, split into two halves:

| Current ecological condition (16 pts) | Successional capacity (16 pts) |
| --- | --- |
| Native woody plant condition | Natural regeneration |
| Native ground layer | Future canopy recruitment |
| Invasive pressure (lower is better) | Vertical structure (number of layers) |
| Soil and site condition | Resilience (how little help it needs) |

Splitting the score reveals something useful. A cluster scoring 15/16 on condition but 7/16 on succession looks healthy today but isn't growing its next generation. A cluster scoring 10/16 and 14/16 may look messy, yet it is heading exactly where we want it. The year-to-year trend matters more than any single score.

### Watching the oaks

We give oak and hickory regeneration its own **Future Canopy Index**. University of Kentucky researchers have raised concern that young white oaks across the region struggle to replace aging canopy trees. Several large trees near our site are already declining. So every year we count oaks and hickories at each stage: seedling, sapling, juvenile, subcanopy and canopy.

> The question behind it: *if today's big trees disappeared, is the next forest already growing underneath?*

### The best sign of all

In our records, a plant that sprouted on its own gets the code N**R, for naturally recruited**. When the data starts filling with NR's, trees, shrubs and wildflowers that nobody planted, the site will no longer be just a collection of native plants. It will be starting to behave like a forest.

## The long view

This is a project measured in decades. Planting is happening in phases over 3-5 years, carried out by volunteer crews. After that, the forest can take the lead. The stages below are planning intervals, not fixed deadlines; actual pace will depend on soil, moisture, weather and what the site itself does.

| Stages | Approx. years | Our main focus |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Establishment | 0–3 | Survival, water stress, deer browse, invasives |
| Competition | 4–7 | Protect desired natives; keep controlling invasives |
| Differentiation | 8–15 | Let winners and losers emerge |
| Young forest | 15–25 | Watch canopy recruitment and natural regeneration |
| Developing forest | 25+ | Minimal intervention; protect natural processes |

The end goal is a structurally diverse, self-renewing native forest. It should regulate itself, recruit new generations of native plants, resist invasive species, protect soil and water, support wildlife, and need less and less help from us each year.

## Come see it grow

The demonstration site is open for anyone to visit, and it will look different every season. If it looks a little wild or uneven, that's by design. You are watching succession in action.

Want to be part of it? Volunteers help with planting days, invasive removal and seasonal monitoring, and no experience is needed. 

[View full post](https://bobolink-greenspace.com/blog/cluster-planting-and-forest-succession)

```json
{
  "@context" : "http://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Jennifer"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-17T18:09:35.740Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-17T18:09:35Z",
  "headline" : "Cluster Planting and Forest Succession",
  "image" : {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "height" : 413,
    "url" : "https://242688317.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na2.net/hubfs/242688317/Cluster%20Planting%20and%20Forest%20Succession.jpg",
    "width" : 826
  },
  "mainEntityOfPage" : "https://bobolink-greenspace.com/blog/cluster-planting-and-forest-succession",
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "height" : 60.0,
      "url" : "https://242688317.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na2.net/hubfs/242688317/Greenspace%20Logo%20copy%20(2).png",
      "width" : 183.79747
    },
    "name" : "blog"
  }
}
```